For the last 10 months, Dean Stevenson has descended deep, deep down into the bowels of Tasmania’s Museum of Old and New Art – Hobart’s subterranean gallery dedicated to the dark and the strange – to sit at a piano and write a piece of music from scratch. No one made Stevenson write 150 compositions; if he’s being completely honest, he wanted to see how far he could push himself until he broke. “And it turned out that it was around 130,” he says mildly.
Under the constant gaze of curious art lovers, the 50-year-old composer has spent the last 10 months writing a piece each day, stopping around 4pm when musicians from Tasmania’s Symphony Orchestra arrive to perform whatever he has written, good or bad. When the performance ended, the composition was shelved and Stevenson started all over again.
The 4PM project is “without doubt the most ambitious” thing Stevenson has ever done, forcing him “to suck at something for a bit and own it”, as he wrote on his website at the beginning. When 4PM was first announced last year, one Mona curator said, “I for one am looking forward to watching him suffer for his art while the clock counts down.”
So, has Stevenson suffered? “Oh my goodness, yes,” he says. “First it was going to be three months, then it became six, then 10. And I could have probably stopped at any time, but I was either writing good music or it didn’t feel unsafe – yet.”
In March, having been in Mona’s depths since July last year, “something went snap in my brain and I had to be taken out of the museum,” he says. “I couldn’t come back for a couple of weeks. To be honest, I’m still not quite back. It was traumatic. I was no longer in control of everything that was going on around me. It was something about being on display all the time, it took a very heavy toll.”
After being removed from Mona, Stevenson took a short break and went on tour, before returning to the gallery to restart 4PM for its sister festival, Dark Mofo. He knows he has been changed by the experiment, but is left wondering exactly how; he suspects he has become a braver musician for it. “Was I getting better at writing music?” he asks. “Or was the music getting better and I was suffering underneath it?
“In the end, I think that’s what happened – the music was getting really good, and I wasn’t doing so well. But I did this to myself. I guess that’s the experiment.”
When he first suggested the idea behind 4PM to Mona founder and friend David Walsh, “it was all going to be about me, look how awesome I am – it was far too egocentric, it would have been terrible.” The idea never went anywhere. In the 20 years between, Stevenson toured as a drummer, composed and taught music. In his students, young and old, he came to observe a shared “crippling anxiety”; most were “so afraid to make something that wasn’t right”.
Finally, he understood: we all must suck at something for a bit and own it.
“We stigmatise mistakes so heavily – if you don’t get it right, it’s better to abandon it,” he says. “Only those with an absolute bloodthirsty passion will keep going, because they can’t not do it. And as a teacher, I was encouraging people to go into the music industry, which I won’t do any more because it’s a terrible industry. Seeing where we sit in the food chain during Covid, I finally understood that unless it is all you can do, it’s a crucifix – and I’m not going to encourage anyone to hang themselves on it.”
Some days by 4pm, he only had “terrible music, just drivel” to show for it. Some days, he left the gallery with great pride. But every day, after each performance, he would be approached by people who told the same story. “It’s curious, but at least once a day they say, ‘I used to play an instrument, and I gave it up.’ You can hear the regret. I always give those people my time, because that’s a really precious moment.”
Surrounded by finished art, he was showing them something exotic: the very process of creation. “You rarely see people making stuff, you always see the end result. And the making is something you do at home in bleak despair, like practising scales. It is just a horrid idea, not something fun. But I can be the guy who hangs his dirty undies out every day,” he says.
Visiting Stevenson in Mona, I spot a message typed on a page on one of the music stands: “Art is never finished. It is only abandoned in an interesting place.” He considers this the greatest lesson and “the antithesis of the panic that we must get things right the first time”.
“If we’re going to make better stuff and be happier, sometimes we have to just go, ‘Oh, that’s enough,’” he says. “Being good enough is actually alright.”
For the two weeks of Dark Mofo, his 4PM sessions have been dedicated to composing parts of a sinfonietta titled With Ukraine. On Tuesday night, it was assembled and performed in Hobart in its entirety; an incredibly moving experience that raised $10,000 for Voices of Children, a charity helping Ukrainian families. And for the first time in 10 months, Stevenson wasn’t performing – he stood backstage and watched as someone else conducted: “A total relief.”
You can listen to every recording from 4PM by signing up for Dean Stevenson’s Patreon. Stevenson will return to Mona for another project in July. 4PM will return to Mona in summer 2023
Guardian Australia travelled to Hobart as a guest of Dark Mofo